IPP> Proposal to not progress the 4 remaining IPP documents and close down the IETF IPP WG

IPP> Proposal to not progress the 4 remaining IPP documents and close down the IETF IPP WG

IPP> Proposal to not progress the 4 remaining IPP documents and close down the IETF IPP WG

Hastings, Tom N hastings at cp10.es.xerox.com
Mon Mar 15 16:48:47 EST 2004


Carl-Uno,

You asked me to proposed actions about the remaining IPP documents that are
in the IETF standards track, since I'm the editor of them.

After talking with you and others, it seems best to withdraw the remaining
IETF IPP documents and close down the IPP WG.  There does not seem to be
sufficient interest in implementing these specifications to warrant
continuing them.  With only one or two companies are interested, it is
better not to pursue these documents in the IETF.  The IPP DL will remain
indefinitely for discussions about IPP RFCs, issues, registrations, etc.


>From the IESG ID Status Tracker, the IPP WG has 4 documents:

1. "Internet Printing Protocol (IPP): IPP Event Notifications and
Subscriptions", R. Herriot and T. Hastings, 2/21/2003,
<draft-ietf-ipp-not-spec-11.txt> (Proposed standard)

Draft Name:  draft-ietf-ipp-not-spec-11.txt (WG <ipp> submission) 
IESG Discussion: Available 
Version:  11 
Intended Status:  Proposed Standard  
On Next Agenda?  No  
Current State:  IESG Evaluation :: Revised ID Needed
Shepherding AD: Hollenbeck, Scott  
Status Date: 2003-02-13    
Note: Revised version needed to address discuss comments  


2.	"Internet Printing Protocol: Requirements for IPP Notifications", T.
Hastings, R Bergman, R deBry, 07/23/2001, <draft-ietf-ipp-not-06.txt>
(Informational)

Draft Name:  draft-ietf-ipp-not-06.txt (WG <ipp> submission) 
IESG Discussion: Not Available 
Version:  06 
Intended Status:  Informational  
On Next Agenda?  No  
Current State:  IESG Evaluation :: Revised ID Needed
Shepherding AD: Hollenbeck, Scott  
Status Date: 2003-02-13    
Note: Revised ID needed to address discuss comments 


3.	"Internet Printing Protocol (IPP): The 'ippget' Delivery Method for
Event Notifications", R. Herriot, T. Hastings, and H. Lewis, 2/21/2003,
<draft-ietf-ipp-notify-get-09.txt>  (Proposed standard)

Draft Name:  draft-ietf-ipp-notify-get-09.txt (WG <ipp> submission) 
IESG Discussion: Not Available 
Version:  09 
Intended Status:  Proposed Standard  
On Next Agenda?  No  
Current State:  IESG Evaluation :: Revised ID Needed
Shepherding AD: Hollenbeck, Scott  
Status Date: 2003-02-13    
Note: Revised ID needed to address discuss comments 


4.	"Internet Printing Protocol (IPP): Job and Printer Administrative
Operations", T. Hastings, R Bergman, Carl Kugler, 07/23/2001,
<draft-ietf-ipp-ops-set2-03.txt>   (Proposed standard)

Draft Name:  draft-ietf-ipp-ops-set2-03.txt (WG <ipp> submission) 
IESG Discussion: Available 
Version:  03 
Intended Status:  Proposed Standard  
On Next Agenda?  No  
Current State:  IESG Evaluation :: Revised ID Needed
Shepherding AD: Hollenbeck, Scott  
Status Date:    
Note: IESG feedback returned to WG 20-Jun-2002; new ID needed with improved
security considerations section   



-----Original Message-----
From: carl at manros.com [mailto:carl at manros.com]
Sent: Monday, March 08, 2004 07:53
To: ipp at pwg.org
Cc: Tom Hastings
Subject: FW: New AD and WG Status Request
Importance: High


Hi all,

I am forwarding this message from our new IETF Area Director. I will need to
consult with the editors to prepare a reply to Scott Hollenbeck. We need to
do that within the next week or so as I will be leaving for a 3 week trip to
Japan on March 20, so please get back to me ASAP to agree on a phone
meeting.

Thanks,

Carl-Uno

Carl-Uno Manros
700 Carnegie Street #3724
Henderson, NV 89052, USA
Tel +1-702-617-9414
Fax +1-702-617-9417
Mob +1-702-525-0727
Email carl at manros.com
Web    www.manros.com

-----Original Message-----
From: Scott Hollenbeck [mailto:sah at 428cobrajet.net]
Sent: Monday, March 08, 2004 6:37 AM
To: Andrew Gierth; Carl-Uno Manros; Claudio Allocchio; Donald Eastlake
3rd; Glenn Parsons; Hiroshi Tamura; John Noerenberg; Lisa Dusseault; Ned
Freed; Pete Resnick; Rik Drummond; Russ Allbery; Steve Hole
Cc: 'Ted Hardie'; sah at 428cobrajet.net
Subject: New AD and WG Status Request
Importance: High


All:

I had a chance to meet with several of you while at the IETF meeting in
Seoul last week.  This note is primarily for those of you that I haven't yet
met.

Ned Freed's IESG term as Applications AD expired with the end of the meeting
in Seoul.  Ted Hardie and I are now your Applications area directors.  My
responsibilities will include the following WGs:

EDIINT (Rik Drummond)
FAX (Claudio Allocchio, Hiroshi Tamura)
IMAPEXT (Pete Resnick)
IPP (Carl-Uno Manros)
MSGTRAK (Steve Hole)
NNTPEXT (Ned Freed, Russ Allbery)
TRADE (Donald Eastlake 3rd)
USEFOR (Pete Resnick, Andrew Gierth)
VPIM (John Noerenberg, Glenn Parsons)
XMPP (Pete Resnick, Lisa Dusseault)

I'd like to get a handle on where each of the these WGs is with respect to
the milestones identified in your charters.  Please take a few moments to
clue me in this week by responding to this message (private reply to me is
OK) with a description of WG status, including any open WG actions.  If
there are outstanding AD actions that you need to have completed, I'd like
to be made aware of those as well.

Thanks!

Looking forward to working with you,
-Scott-




More information about the Ipp mailing list