[MFD] April 28th 2011 - Conference Call Notes

[MFD] April 28th 2011 - Conference Call Notes

[MFD] April 28th 2011 - Conference Call Notes

Ira McDonald blueroofmusic at gmail.com
Thu Apr 28 22:56:21 UTC 2011


Hi Andrew,

Thanks for these minutes!

I saved your note to a PDF and stored in the usual place at:

  ftp://ftp.pwg.org/pub/pwg/mfd/minutes/pwg-mfd-minutes-20110428.pdf

Cheers,
- Ira


On Thu, Apr 28, 2011 at 4:04 PM, Mitchell, Andrew (Solutions Architect) <
andrew.mitchell2 at hp.com> wrote:

> Attendees: Andrew Mitchell, Bill Wagner, Glen Petrie, Ira McDonald, Peter
> Zehler, Jerry Thrasher, Nancy Chen
>
> Agenda Review – No additions
>
> Approval of meeting minutes from previous meeting - Approved
>
> MFD Model and Common Semantics:
>
> Destination-Uri has various spellings – correct in schema, incorrect in
> fax-out, various spelling
> Changed in the Model and Common Semantics
> - Has anyone noticed any diagrams in Model and Common Semantics that don't
> work?
> Diagrams in fax-out are out of date
>
> Schema Corrections:
>
> Table 79:
>
> Restart, Shutdown, and Startup services have issue in schema
> Items like Id (local ID) and Service Type are remnants of an old direction
>
> IsAcceptingJobs and IsAcceptingResources should also be available in
> StartupService
>
> RestartServiceRequestType should have:
>
> ElementsNaturalLanguage
> IsAcceptingJobs – or – IsAcceptingResources
> Message
> RequestingUserName
> StartServicesPaused
>
> Symbology for or | is not defined anywhere, add to terminology or
> conventions
>
> RequestedElements should be removed from GetDocuments
>
> ElementNaturalLanguage should be added to CancelMy<service>Jobs
>
> FaxOutServices should be called UnsupportedElements instead of
> UnsupportedAttributes
>
> All instances of UnsupportedElements should be concatenated titlecase words
>
> 7.3.1.20  has a yellow section, with a lower case must, should be upper
> case MUST (and yellow should be removed before final).
>
> Edits to schema are being made in-place without a change to documents or
> version number.
> One more update to be done of files on PWG site before the named version is
> final.
> Note again: the number will not be changed.
>
> Copy Service: the date for the copy services should be 4-15, ie the date
> that the last call vote end. (only the CS version, but should be backdated
> to the final day in which it was approved)
>
> Review of the FaxOut spec:
>
> Global comment – header and footer are different sizes
>
> Ira, boiler plate from Copy service should be copied to FaxOut as well
>
> Lines 194-195, FaxOut used as a verb, needs to be modified facsimile
> documents and can remove "that use their computers to FaxOut".
> Next line can also be modified to use facsimile documents
>
> Is Section 5 necessary, or should it be moved into section 6.
> The same comment was made against CopyService in last call.
> Make 5 a subsection of 6 (6.1) which also renumbers sections so its really
> 5.1.
>
> Figure 13 out of date DestinationURIs s/b DestinationUris
>
> Extension Points in Schema?
>
> We will skip adding attribute extension points based on the benefits do not
> outweigh the cost
> Most importantly it breaks backward compatibility
> All the sequences have element extension points already
>
> GetActiveFaxOutJobs has the list of JobSummaries as a mandatory response
> element, but its optional in the MFD Model, response is while the list is
> mandatory, there can be zero elements in the list.
> Jobs can not leave JobHistory until they are durably logged to meet various
> regulatory requirements in multiple regions around the world.
> Since the MFD Model says this is optional, we will add a clarifying
> statement that this is an augmentation to the MFD model where this is
> optional.
>
> Pete will do an update to then then we will do a PWG Last Call.
>
> Current Status of the Specifications:
>
> Model and Comment Semantics: Approved and awaiting final updates including
> putting the final document number
> Copy Service: Currently in PWG Last Call
> FaxIn Service: Interim Draft, Updated Draft due in May prior to the F2F
> (Ira), we need a prototype volunteer for FaxIn or we can't put out for last
> call.
> FaxOut Service: Reviewed, and being submitted for PWG Last Call
> Print Service: Approved
> Scan Service: Approved, but new revision is planned. Will reduce size and
> accommodate IPP Scan, as well as take into account MFD Model and Common
> Semantics final spec.
> Resource Service: Approved (being left alone for now)
> MFD System Service: Now named MFD System Control Service, updated draft of
> spec due prior to next F2F (Pete)
>
> Services remaining:
> EmailIn, EmailOut, and a Transform service
>
> Next teleconference next week (5/5/2011).
>
> Pete to get a version of the system spec out and we'll discuss that.
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> --
> This message has been scanned for viruses and
> dangerous content by MailScanner, and is
> believed to be clean.
>
> _______________________________________________
> mfd mailing list
> mfd at pwg.org
> https://www.pwg.org/mailman/listinfo/mfd
>

-- 
This message has been scanned for viruses and
dangerous content by MailScanner, and is
believed to be clean.

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://www.pwg.org/pipermail/mfd/attachments/20110428/03f4fc38/attachment-0001.html>


More information about the mfd mailing list