JMP> Final IPP/JMP job-state and job-state-reasons

JMP> Final IPP/JMP job-state and job-state-reasons

Caruso,Angelo Angelo_Caruso at wb.xerox.com
Wed Jun 11 12:00:07 EDT 1997


Tom wrote:


> 5. We agreed that job-state-reasons are all OPTIONAL.
> 
> The following JMP sentence will be included in the JmJobStateReasons1TC
> textual-convention:
> 
> Implementation of these values is OPTIONAL, i.e., an agent NEED NOT
> implement them, even if the device supports the functionality represented by
> the reason and is available to the agent.


The last part of the last sentence here, "i.e., an agent NEED NOT 
 implement them, even if the device supports the functionality 
 represented by the reason and is available to the agent", is 
 pratically encouraging implementors NOT to implement the job state 
 reasons. Why not just say "they're optional", PERIOD? I suggest the 
 wording be shortened to,


"Implementation of these values is OPTIONAL."


for both JMP and IPP.


Thanks,
Angelo



More information about the Jmp mailing list