Hi,
Yes, I requested Rick change "integer" -> "INTEGER" in
my previous review.
All underlying ASN.1 types are always uppercase. And
all tokens in ASN.1 productions are case-sensitive.
Cheers,
- Ira
On Nov 16, 2007 7:32 PM, <Ron.Bergman at ricoh-usa.com> wrote:
>> Raymond,
>> You are correct. Use "INTEGER" (upper case).
>> Regards,
> Ron Bergman
>>> "Raymond Rogers"
> <ReRogers at SYMON.c> om> To
> Sent by: <Richard_Landau at Dell.com>, "Ira
>owner-pdm at pwg.org McDonald" <blueroofmusic at gmail.com>
> cc
> <pdm at pwg.org>
> 11/16/2007 04:19 Subject
> PM RE: PDM> New files on FTP
>>>>>>>>>>>> Rick,
> Here is part of the output from my MIB compiler.
>> One thing that stands out is that the "SYNTAX integer" phrase in the
> textual-conventions should be "SYNTAX INTEGER", Ira would you verify this
> please. Most of the other errors seem to be based on problems in the XML
> source.
>> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(42) : Warning 20 : Node "pwg" with OID "1.3.6.1.4.1.2699"
> created
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(42) : Warning 20 : Node "mibs" with OID
> "1.3.6.1.4.1.2699.1" created
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(77) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(93) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(113) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(127) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(139) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(154) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(167) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(168) : Warning 6 : Item "True" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(169) : Warning 6 : Item "False" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(180) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(189) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(190) : Warning 6 : Item "Zoom" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(191) : Warning 6 : Item "Letterbox" must start with
> lowercase letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(191) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(191) : Error 19 : Missing ")"
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(191) : Warning 6 : Item ":" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(191) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(191) : Error 19 : Missing ")"
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(191) : Warning 6 : Item "(" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(191) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(192) : Warning 6 : Item "Widescreen" must start with
> lowercase letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(192) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(192) : Error 19 : Missing ")"
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(192) : Warning 6 : Item ":" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(192) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(192) : Error 19 : Missing ")"
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(192) : Warning 6 : Item "(" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(192) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(193) : Warning 6 : Item "Crop" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(194) : Warning 6 : Item "Window" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(194) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(194) : Error 19 : Missing ")"
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(194) : Warning 6 : Item ":" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(194) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(194) : Error 19 : Missing ")"
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(194) : Warning 6 : Item "(" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(194) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(195) : Warning 6 : Item "Fill" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(195) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(195) : Error 19 : Missing ")"
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(195) : Warning 6 : Item ":" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(195) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(195) : Error 19 : Missing ")"
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(195) : Warning 6 : Item "(" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(195) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(196) : Warning 6 : Item "Fullscreen" must start with
> lowercase letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(197) : Warning 6 : Item "Stadium" must start with
> lowercase letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(204) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(206) : Warning 6 : Item "6300" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(206) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(206) : Error 6 : Invalid number
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(206) : Error 19 : Missing ")"
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(207) : Warning 6 : Item "7200" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(207) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(207) : Error 6 : Invalid number
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(207) : Error 19 : Missing ")"
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(208) : Warning 6 : Item "9300" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(208) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(208) : Error 6 : Invalid number
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(208) : Error 19 : Missing ")"
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(217) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(218) : Warning 6 : Item "High" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(219) : Warning 6 : Item "Normal" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(220) : Warning 6 : Item "Low" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(221) : Warning 6 : Item "Other" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(228) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(229) : Warning 6 : Item "Alive" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(230) : Warning 6 : Item "Not" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(230) : Error 19 : Missing "("
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(230) : Error 6 : Invalid number
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(230) : Error 19 : Missing ")"
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(230) : Warning 6 : Item "Alive" must start with lowercase
> letter
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(239) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(253) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(268) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(281) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(294) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(305) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(318) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(346) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(366) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(376) : Error 23 : Item "integer" is not defined or
> imported
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(65) : Warning 15 : Size already defined
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(189) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(189) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(189) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(189) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(189) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(189) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(189) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(189) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(189) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(189) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(204) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(204) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(204) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
> E:\SKELET~1.MIB(228) : Warning 19 : Enumerated list is not unique
>> Regards,
> Raymond Rogers
> Symon Communications, Inc.
> (972)543-9586
>> From: owner-pdm at pwg.org [mailto:owner-pdm at pwg.org] On Behalf Of
>Richard_Landau at Dell.com> Sent: Friday, November 16, 2007 5:12 PM
> To: pdm at pwg.org> Subject: PDM> New files on FTP
>>>> Improved, I hope, MIB translation.
>>> in ftp://ftp.pwg.org/pub/pwg/pdm/objects/ we have new
> skeleton-final.mib
> skeleton-final-names-too-long.txt
> xsl-mib-fragments-20071115.zip
> xsl-mib-translate-20071115.zip
>>> Ira, I think this MIB fixes the problems with clause order and duplicate
> OIDs. There are improved still rough DEFVALs and some bad enums; I hope
> the original authors will fix them soon. Please give it/them a turn thru
> various compilers to see how much crud remains. Thanks.
>>> rick
> ----------------------
> Richard_Landau(at)dell(dot)com, Stds & System Mgt Architecture, CTO Office
> +1-512-728-9023, One Dell Way, RR5-3, MS RR5-09, Round Rock, TX 78682
>>>> Notice of Confidentiality: This transmission contains information that may
> be confidential and that may also be privileged. Unless you are the
> intended recipient of the message (or authorized to receive it for the
> intended recipient) you may not copy, forward, or otherwise use it, or
> disclose its contents to anyone else. If you have received this
> transmission in error, please notify us immediately and delete it from your
> system.
>>>
--
Ira McDonald (Musician / Software Architect)
Chair - Linux Foundation Open Printing WG
Blue Roof Music / High North Inc
PO Box 221 Grand Marais, MI 49839
work: +1-906-494-2434
home: +1-906-494-2697
email: blueroofmusic at gmail.com