Teleconference details:
NEXT: Tuesday March 18 2003 (USA)
Time: 8 AM (US PST)
Number: 866-639-4738
Participant PIN: 7855605
If Trouble with Above Try:
Toll Access Number: 574-935-6700
Participant PIN: 7855605
Agenda:
1) closeDocument
2) The Mandatory vs. Supported language action (see 1.1 below)
3) FetchJobs filter example note (see 1.3 below)
4) Other Spec. Changes Review
5) Ready for Last Call
Meeting 03/04/03
PSI Working Group:
*Alan Berkema *Dave Hall *Gail Songer
*Jerry Thasher Harry Lewis *Ted Tronson
Peter Mierau Peter Zehler Paul Tykodi
*Bob Taylor Don Levinstone Lee Farrell
Don Wright Kirk Ocke *Ira Mcdonald
Amir Shahindoust Alain Regnier Mike Haller
*Darrell Hopp
* = attendance
Minutes:
Agenda:
1) Alain's e-mail Questions
2) addDocumnetByPush review
3) Ready for Last Call
4) ?
2) Once addDocumnetByPush is submitted no more addDoc operations
permitted until data has completed. Other methods such as cancel or
status are OK. closeDocument indicates that the data transfer has
completed. Still some discussion pending on this method.
1) Alain's questions
1.1) What is meant exactly by Method Support in the specification?
Do we talk about the "implementation" or the "utilization" of an
interface or a method?
If we talk about the implementation, I don't really see why "CreateJob"
and "CloseJob" are mandatory for Clients. (Why should Clients implement
these methods?)
Method support means the method shall be implemented. Dave will fix the
specfifcation
to state the intent more clearly in terms of shall be implemented and client
is
required to call etc.
1.2) 5.5.6 Regarding the filtering criteria of GetJobs, I'm not sure why
we have to
support element by element filtering. Isn't "group of elements"
filtering enough?
Do we really need such a granularity?
It makes implementation more complex, and I'm not sure the gain in term
of bandwidth, or XML processing is that good. (and you have to process
the XML document anyway)
Believe that the level of filtering is appropriate. The complexity is in
the Sevice and having less granularity may actually make it more complex
for the Client.
1.3) 5.12 for FetchJobs, what else than JobURI, JobAccountingUserID and
JobPassword might be needed in the jobFilter?
Do we expect the Print Service to do any kind of filtering on other
elements?
These are not the only possibilities. The example should note that these
values
are the only possibilities.
3) Determine if the spec is ready to begin a 4 week last call cycle
F2F April 4 2003
Line by line editorial review
Last Call Straw Vote - need concrete comments to vote against
Interop Proto testing plans and schedule
3/24 is the last date to post slides other presentations for F2F
Action: Prepare PSI presentation for FSG F2F
Owner: Dave & Alan
Status:
4) Get Jobs - improved language
Only the jobs that the user is authorized to view shall be returned.