Elliot:
I have a problem with an assumption made:
"Because a client has control over the data it generates, it only needs one way
to achieve a given effect; we don't have a need to support multiple legacy
variations. Accordingly, we only specify an attribute as required when there is
no equivalent CSS property. In cases where both exist, CSS is preferred."
and therefore with the conclusion drawn.
We originally envisioned that XHTML-Print would be used not only as a way for a
device like a cellphone or PDA to print but also as a way for these and other
devices to be able to print a web page. Your assumption that the device has
control over how it generates data is correct but only for the data it generates
and not for a web page surfed to on that device that now needs to be printed.
For that reason, we need to consider the common usage of elements and attributes
as encountered on the web. While a CSS property may be the intellectually
preferred method, if the more common method is not CSS, we should probably
mandate the more common method but recommend the CSS method.
**********************************************
Don Wright don at lexmark.com
Member, IEEE SA Standards Board
PatCom Chair, SCC Liaison
Member, IEEE-ISTO Board of Directors
f.wright at ieee.org / f.wright at computer.org
Director, Alliances & Standards
Lexmark International
740 New Circle Rd
Lexington, Ky 40550
859-825-4808 (phone) 603-963-8352 (fax)
**********************************************
ElliottBradshaw%oaktech.com at interlock.lexmark.com on 08/13/2002 04:25:38 PM
To: xp%pwg.org at interlock.lexmark.com
cc: (bcc: Don Wright/Lex/Lexmark)
Subject: XP> Proposed XHTML-Print amendment
Folks,
Attached is a proposal that Jim Bigelow and I worked up to handle
attributes in XHTML-Print. This document describes new material (and a few
changes) to be added to a future version of the spec.
We would like to have your feedback ASAP. Our goal is to bring a consensus
version to Santa Fe for a vote.
Your comments, please.
E.
(See attached file: XPattributes.doc)
------------------------------------------
Elliott Bradshaw
Director, Software Engineering
Oak Technology Imaging Group
781 638-7534
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: XPattributes.doc
Type: application/msword
Size: 45056 bytes
Desc: Mac Word 3.0
Url : http://www.pwg.org/archives/xp/attachments/20020814/5c8b5eaa/XPattributes-0001.doc