IPP Mail Archive: IPP> Re: Last Call comment to remove redir

IPP Mail Archive: IPP> Re: Last Call comment to remove redir

IPP> Re: Last Call comment to remove redirect URL and status code from IPPGET

From: Dennis Carney (dcarney@us.ibm.com)
Date: Thu Aug 01 2002 - 11:20:00 EDT

  • Next message: Harry Lewis: "RE: IPP> ADM - IPP Working Group Last Call for "(IPP): Event Notifications and Subscriptions" and "(IPP): The 'ippget'Delivery Method for Event Notifications " by July 31, 2002"

    At the risk of looking like I'm simply taking Harry's side since he and I
    work together, I'm going to comment nonetheless.

    This process *does* seem a bit arbitrary to me. I could probably go back
    through (well, maybe not me, but I'm sure Tom could ;-) any document the
    PWG has produced looking for things that "don't look right". Then I could
    bring them up, and possibly get significant support in their
    "not-looking-right-ness". However, in theory, whatever it is I'm bringing
    up has already been discussed and decided upon in the past, by a number of
    people who had their heads clearly focused on the task at hand, unlike now,
    where probably fewer people are paying attention, and even those people
    might not have really had their minds focused on the subject for months
    (years?).

    I think if a "problem" is discovered in a document, it should be brought
    up, as Tom did. However, even if only one person pipes up to explain why
    it is not a problem (it's a feature! :-), I would think the conversation
    should end there--a conscious decision was made on the subject and opening
    up documents to continual re-editing would seem to be a bad precedent.

    If there is real consensus that this redirect mechanism is a "problem",
    sure, let's consider getting rid of it. But if the consensus is simply
    that we're not sure whether anyone is going to use it, I believe we must
    have more useful things to do with our time than debate this.

    Just my 2 cents worth...

    Dennis Carney
    IBM Printing Systems



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Thu Aug 01 2002 - 11:35:16 EDT