PSI F2F Meeting Minutes 12/04/2003 (Provo, Utah)


I.    Attendees.
     
	Lee Farrell
	Yiruo Yang
	Harry Lewis
	Jerry Thrasher
	Jeff Christensen
	Ted Tronson
	Alain Regnier
	Bill Wagner
	Ide Kentaro
	
	By Phone:
	Ira McDonald
	Dave Hall
	Alan Berkema
	Pete Zehler
	

II.	Review Agenda (see Alan's PPT)

        A.	Introductions
        B.	Call For Intellectual Property                  
        C.	Review and Approve Minutes from NY Meeting.
	  D.	Review Agenda
        E.	MRD Approval?
        F.	Specification Review (20031126)
	  G.  Next Steps
	  	
III.	Intellectual Property

	Call for IP was made. No responses in the meeting.
        
IV.	Review and approve minutes from October Meeting.
	No changes (Approved)

V.	Review Agenda.
	See above
	
VI.	MRD Approval

MRD has been completed last call.
	
***	Action: Alan will post the MRD for formal vote.

VII.  Specification Review (Intent is that last call scheduled for January 2004.)
				

	Review of 11/26/2003 draft.
		(changes will be reflected in the last call document)

	General Editorial: Tables and Figures need to be identified and listed.
				(i.e. need table of figures etc.)	

	Section 5
		Reminder: Namespace must be finally defined with CS approval date.

	Section 5.1 
		(Removed PSI Service Root URL that mentioned UPnP 2.0)

		ToDo: Need a Reference added to WSIL.

		Discussed the moving of the Method conformance requirements to a separate 
		conformance section.  (decided to add a cross reference at the beginning of each
		interface description that points to the conformance section to remind the reader)
		Also a note in the front of the specification about the conformance section.

	Section 5.4 (5.4.3)
		Fixed URL identifiers in figures.  Added example of a targetDeviceIdentifier
		filter and clarified the use of wildcard in the filter.

	Todo: Parameter support(requirement) tables are not completed throughout all sections of the 
		specification.

	Section 5.5.8 (Epson issue 1)
		Improve description and add XML frag. example for the jobFilterElements 
		parameter. (see updated specification)

	Section 5.5.12
		Added documentFilterElements examples. (see update specification)

	Section 5.5.16-18 (Epson issue 3)
		Discussed the issue of multi-file input documents (i.e., zip files) and how they
		are retrieved after "transformation" (currently the output of a multi-file tranformed 
		zip file or email reference is a single stream)
		(no resolution as of now, post PSI 1.0)

	Section 5.5.9 (Epson issue 2)
		Discussed the issue that the PSI client must poll a PSI server for pulling of document
		data.	Decided to add a return parameter (callbackInterval) to GetJobs, GetJobElements and 
		GetDocumentElements that indicates a "suggested" time to check back if the document/job 
		data is not available yet.
		(see updated specification for details)

	Section 5.6.2, 5.6.4	
		Added callbackInterval to FetchNextJob, FetchNextDocumentByPull, and 
		FetchNextDocumentByValue to alleviate the polling traffic. (Epson issue 2)

	Section 7.2.3
		Target Device Identifiers that use pwg-unc need to use the smb instead.
		(see updated specification) Remove pwg-unc....

	Section 8.1.1
		Editorial todo: clean undefined and broken references (throughout spec.)

	Section 8.9
		Added statement about the max allowed value of the callbackInterval as it 
		relates to the hold time of the job/document data on the Print Service. 
		(i.e., callbackInterval can't be larger than half the data's hold time)

***************************
End of Specification Review
***************************		

VIII. Next Steps

	a. Planning a last call for PSI 1.0 that starts by Dec. 12, 2003 and ends on 
	   Jan. 15, 2004.  With a formal vote to follow.		
	
	b. Interoperability events to validate and advance the PSI 1.0 CS.

	c. Possible full Transformation Service extension to PSI 1.0. 
		Will need to re-charter the PSI group to add the transformation service
		in the scope. 
		Will also need a new requirments document.

	d. Plan on a half day PSI meeting at the Feb. F2F.
				
IX.  Next Phone conference Call on Tuesday Jan. 6 ,2004. one planned to follow
	on Jan. 13, 2004.

Meeting adjourned.......