At 04:18 PM 9/26/96 EDT, you wrote:
>Randy,
>In response to your e-mail with regards to closing down the Printer
>MIB, I took a look at the open issues and here are my opinions.
>
>- Addition of new Channels Group (aka MagicCookie)
> Host Software groups feel that the simple group as proposed by
> David Kellerman would be sufficient for them.
>> My opinion is that this issue should wait until November so Jay and
>> Dave can join in the discussion of this issue.
>
>> Not closed until after November meeting.
>
>- Relabeling of Optional Groups as Conditionally Mandatory
> ** Action Item from last meeting was for each printer vendor to see
> if they did not implement an optional group in RFC 1759 but would
> have been required to implement the group if it was labeled as
> conditionally mandatory.
>> This one is simple. Change optional groups to conditionally mandatory.
>> I don't see that we have any choice.
>
>> Closed after October meeting.
>
>- Mininum access specified for R/W objects
> ** Action Item from last meeting was that Bob Setterbo will initate
> a review of Min/Max access including a R/W object audit
>> I think we will have to put a Min Access on each R/W object. I will
>> bring a list of the R/W objects to the October meeting. I will glad
>> send a private list to anyone who requests it. I do not want to
>> send out to the entire mailing list because of it's size.
>
>> Closed after October meeting.
>
>- Channel Type TC
> This was closed at the San Diego meeting but Jay Martin raised
> an issue on the mailing list that he still thought the
> definition might be wrong. Bob Setterbo and Bob Pentecost from
> Adobe and HP respectively were asked to respond from their
> companies.
>> My suggestion is to go with the following definitions. This appears
>> to be the best that we have unless we hear differently from Adobe
>> and HP.
>> chPort9100(11), -- Bi-directional printing protocol
>> -- utilizing TCP port 9101 for control
>> -- and TCP port 9100 for data.
>> AppSocket(12), -- a bi-directional, LPD-like
>> -- protocol using 9101 for
>> -- control and 9100 for data
>> -- Adobe Systems, Inc.
>
>> Closed after October meeting.
>
>- New Interpreter - JCL
> ** Action Item from last meeting was for Tom Hastings to post his
> proposal to the pwg mailing list and to review if he could change
> the proposal from JCL to XJCL.
>> Tom should be able to resolve this one quickly.
>
>> Closed after October meeting.
>
>- Problem of referencing hrMIB when it hasn't progressed
> Alternatives
> 1. Take over the hrMIB, deprecate all but what we want.
> 2. Bring needed hrMIB objects inside the printer MIB. Don't change
> objects but assign new OIDs.
> 3. Define status without the hrMIB.
>> This one is going to take Deidre's involvement. I see this one staying
>> open for awhile.
>
>> Open after November.
>
>- prtAlert 1115
> Should be TonerCartridgeMissing
>> This one should be minor.
>
>> Closed after October.
>
>In summary, I project that we will close 5 issues after the October meeting
>(final closure will be done via the mailing list). We will still have
>2 issues open past the November meeting. One issue may be able to be closed
>quickly during November. However the second issue will drag on for a few more
>months.
>Deidre and I discussed submitting the draft without the Host Resources MIB
being
>resolved and she thought that was OK.
>
>Lloyd Young Phone: (606) 232-5150
>Lexmark International Inc. Fax: (606) 232-6740
>740 New Circle Road NW internet: lpyoung@lexmark.com
>Lexington, KY 40511
>
>
===================================================
Bob Setterbo <bsetterbo@adobe.com>
Voice 415-962-3521
Location: Adobe Emeryville
===================================================