PMP> Comments on latest Printer MIB

PMP> Comments on latest Printer MIB

Bob Pentecost bpenteco at boi.hp.com
Fri Jun 13 18:45:14 EDT 1997


Sorry this is late. I've been spending my Printer MIB time on =
localization issues.


I have the following comment on latest Printer MIB:


1) If coverOpened and coverClosed are duplicated, one of them should =
have their name changed and the 501 and 502 values should be noted as =
deprecated. I don't think they should be removed entirely since they =
were part of RFC 1759 (as doorOpen and doorClosed).




And to comment on the issue(s) raised by others:


I agree with Angelo...


> ----------
From:  Caruso,Angelo[SMTP:Angelo_Caruso at wb.xerox.com]
> Sent:  Monday, June 09, 1997 1:50 PM
> To:  pmp at pwg.org
> Subject:  PMP> Still two definitions of Busy
>=20
> Editorial comments on the current draft =
(draft-ietf-printmib-mib-info-02.txt):
>=20
> On page 18 of the current draft there is a definition for Busy /=20
>  Temporarily Unavailable which appears as part of the same paragraph=20
>  for the definition of Unavailable. I believe this should be removed=20
>  since there is a second definition for Busy on page 19. I thought we=20
>  had agreed to this previously.
>=20
> The table on page 19 has 'Normal' as the first entry. I thought we had =


>  agreed to change the first entry from 'Normal' to 'Idle'.  There is =
no=20
>  definition for 'Normal' but there IS a definition for 'Idle'.
>=20
> There are many instances of text formatting problems (line wraps and=20
>  indentations) in the draft.
>=20
> Angelo=20
>=20
> Bob Pentecost
HP



More information about the Pmp mailing list